Skip to content
Home » Blog » Hegseth Fired Her Last August. This August the Party Made Her a Target Seat.

Hegseth Fired Her Last August. This August the Party Made Her a Target Seat.

💡

Key Insight: The committee is spending on veterans in seats it has no business winning

On 20 August the House campaign arm added five candidates to its target program, three of them veterans. The Nancy Lacore South Carolina bid is the clearest case. She’s a retired three-star admiral running in a district the forecasters call Solid Republican.

What the Nancy Lacore South Carolina addition tells you

The House Democrats’ campaign arm named five more candidates to its Red to Blue program last Thursday. That brings the roster to 37 with about ten weeks left. But Red to Blue isn’t an endorsement so much as a supply line. It means staff, training, fundraising help and the committee’s attention.

Three of the five served. First there’s Leela Gray, the retired Army brigadier general who won Florida’s thirteenth district nomination six days earlier. Second, Zach Dembo, a former Navy judge advocate running in Kentucky’s open sixth. Lacore is the third. Maine State Auditor Matt Dunlap and former Representative Tom Perriello round out the list.

Now look at where those seats sit. Four of the five are in districts Donald Trump won by double digits in 2024. Inside Elections rates Kentucky’s sixth, South Carolina’s first and Virginia’s fifth as Solid Republican. Meanwhile Florida’s thirteenth and Maine’s second are Likely Republican. So the committee just spent its August news cycle on a slate where not one race is rated close.

⚡ Fast Facts: the 20 August Red to Blue additions

  • The five: Leela Gray in Florida, Zach Dembo in Kentucky, Nancy Lacore in South Carolina, Matt Dunlap in Maine, Tom Perriello in Virginia
  • Veterans among them: three of five, all with lengthy federal service records
  • Program size: 37 candidates now, with the general election on 3 November
  • The ratings: Inside Elections has three of the five Solid Republican and two Likely Republican
  • Lacore’s service: 35 years in the Navy, helicopter pilot to vice admiral, chief of the Navy Reserve over roughly 59,000 sailors
  • Her removal: 22 August 2025, one year into a job that normally runs four
  • The seat: open, after Nancy Mace finished fifth in the 9 June Republican primary for governor

A year, almost to the day

Lacore spent 35 years in uniform. She flew helicopters, led at Camp Lemonnier in Djibouti and served in Kabul. Later she ran Naval District Washington, then finished as chief of the Navy Reserve. That job put roughly 59,000 sailors under her.

Then on 22 August 2025 she was removed, twelve months into a post that usually lasts four years. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth cut her loose the same week as two others. One was Lieutenant General Jeffrey Kruse, who ran the Defense Intelligence Agency. The other was Rear Admiral Milton Sands of Naval Special Warfare Command. Lacore has said she was told the change took effect at once, and that she walked out of the Pentagon an hour later. The Defense Department didn’t respond when reporters asked about her claim that no cause was given.

She announced for Congress in January. Then in June she led a crowded Democratic primary with over 36 percent, ahead of Coast Guard veteran Mac Deford on 29, before winning the runoff on 23 June. Her Republican opponent is Charleston County Councilwoman Jenny Costa Honeycutt. Trump carried the district by about 13 points two years ago.

❝

I was removed from my position without cause

— Nancy Lacore, in the January post announcing her campaign

Republicans say this is theatre, and they have a point

Give the objection its full run, because the ratings back it up. On the numbers, the Republicans are closer to right than we’d like.

NRCC spokesman Mike Marinella said the committee could keep throwing darts at the map and calling wherever they land a battleground. That’s a cheap line, but check it against Inside Elections and it mostly holds. Three of these five races are rated Solid Republican, which is the category for seats nobody expects to change hands. Naming a candidate to a target program in late August costs a committee almost nothing and buys a friendly news cycle in five media markets at once.

There’s a stronger version of the same objection. Red to Blue is a resource call, not a forecast. Candidates qualify by hitting marks on fundraising, field work and local backing. So it measures how well a campaign is run, not how winnable a seat is. And a well-run campaign in a Trump plus 13 district is still a campaign in a Trump plus 13 district.

Then there’s the question of whether the life story travels. Lacore’s removal was a national story, covered because it fit a pattern of senior officers being pushed out. Whether it means much to a voter in Beaufort County worrying about a power bill is a different question. Lacore’s own answer is telling, since she talks about the cost of living rather than about Hegseth.

3 of 5
New Red to Blue additions who served
Trump +13
South Carolina’s first district in 2024
37
Candidates in the program with ten weeks left

Why we think the committee is reading this correctly

Here’s the part that matters, and it runs against what we’ve published twice this month.

In Florida on 18 August, two well-funded veteran Democrats lost primaries to local officeholders. A week earlier in Massachusetts, polling found the founder of the veteran recruitment movement trailing among veterans in his own primary. Both results say a service record doesn’t move Democratic voters choosing between Democrats. We wrote that, and we still think it’s right.

But notice where the committee is placing these candidates. Not in blue-seat primaries. Instead they’re in Kentucky, South Carolina and Virginia, where any Democrat who wins has to pull a real number of Trump voters. That’s the only claim this site has ever made about military service. It helps with independents and soft Republicans in a general election, against a Republican, in a place where a Democrat needs permission to be heard.

So the committee and the primary results aren’t in conflict. They’re testing different things. The party spent this year learning the hard way that a uniform is a weak tool in a primary, and it’s now placing veterans where the tool is meant to work. Whether it does work is what 3 November will answer. These five seats are unusually clean tests, because the districts are red enough that nothing else could explain a win.

🎯

Strategic Insight: a Solid Republican rating makes this a better experiment, not a worse one

Analysts treat these ratings as a verdict on whether a race is worth watching. For our purposes the opposite is true. In a toss-up district, a veteran Democrat who wins tells you almost nothing, because the seat was going to be close whoever ran. In a district Trump carried by 13, a veteran Democrat who comes within five points has demonstrated something that no toss-up result can. Watch the margins in South Carolina’s first, Kentucky’s sixth and Virginia’s fifth on election night, whether or not any of them flips. Those three numbers will tell you more about whether service moves general-election voters than the whole toss-up column put together.

📅 From the Pentagon to the Lowcountry ballot

22 August 2025
Hegseth removes Lacore as chief of the Navy Reserve, one year into a four-year post
January 2026
Lacore announces for South Carolina’s first district, saying she was removed without cause
9 June 2026
Nancy Mace finishes fifth in the governor’s primary; Lacore leads her own with 36 percent
23 June 2026
Lacore wins the Democratic runoff over Coast Guard veteran Mac Deford
20 August 2026
The DCCC adds her to Red to Blue with Gray, Dembo, Dunlap and Perriello
3 November 2026
Lacore faces Jenny Costa Honeycutt in a district Trump won by roughly 13

What to watch between now and November

Three things are worth tracking. Money is the first of them.

Red to Blue brings staff and fundraising help rather than a cheque. So the test is whether outside spending follows into any of these five districts. If the committee names candidates in August and no money arrives by October, the NRCC’s dart-throwing line was right. But if money does move into a Solid Republican seat, somebody’s private polling disagrees with the public ratings.

Second, watch whether the ratings move. Inside Elections and the Cook Political Report both revise through the autumn. A shift from Solid to Likely Republican in any of these three seats would be the first outside confirmation that the committee saw something real.

Third, watch how Lacore uses the firing. So far she’s kept it in her life story rather than her closing pitch, which is the careful choice in a district full of military families with split loyalties. If that changes in October, her own numbers are telling her the Hegseth story sells better in the Lowcountry than she expected. That would be worth knowing for every veteran Democrat running against this administration’s record.

The primaries went badly. The general is the actual test.

We’ve spent August publishing evidence that a service record doesn’t win Democratic primaries. These five seats are where the narrower claim finally gets examined.

Leave a Reply

Latest Strategy Updates